The significance of Para Completion or Paragraph Completion
Para Completion (PC) has been a regular feature of CAT papers since 2005. Before we solve the Para Completion questions, we must try to understand what the questions test. Para Completion Questions test the candidate’s thought process, their ability to conclude, summarize, continue or keep track of an idea or an argument.
The paragraph completion questions are very similar to the parajumbles questions. The only difference is that in the parajumbles questions you arrange sentences such that they form a coherent paragraph, while in paragraph completion you have to fit the last sentence such that it gels with the rest of the paragraph.
Let’s look at the question direction of Para Completion questions. It says: Each of the following questions has a paragraph from which the last sentence has been deleted. From the given options, choose the one that completes the paragraph in the most appropriate way.
The question asks us to complete the paragraph in the most appropriate way, not in the most logical way. Students preparing for GMAT must have come across similar questions in which the questions ask the test taker to logically complete the passage.
Since what is appropriate is a subjective view, test-takers often make a choice based on their intuition, leaving room for uncertainty. Often the accuracy percentage is around 50%.
The last line of a paragraph usually continues a discussion/description or concludes an argument. In short, there is either continuity or a conclusion
What should the last line have and not have
If the last line is a conclusion, then:
- The last line should bring the paragraph to a smooth end; it should not be abrupt.
- The conclusion should be logically derivable from the premises already stated or from pieces of evidence already cited and should reflect the correct line of reasoning
- The outcome should focus on the main idea of the passage.
- The conclusion must be relevant to the critical issues discussed in the passage
If the last line is a continuation of an idea, then:
- The last line must not have a new element, not at all related to the ideas discussed earlier
- The last line should have structure and order very similar to the preceding ideas
- The logical arrangement of the last line should be such that it gives a logical flow to the entire paragraph
- The idea in the last line should reflect a smooth transition from the idea in the preceding lines
Above all, the candidate must ensure that the tone of the last line is consistent with the tone of the entire paragraph.
Let’s take a simple example of Para Completion.
Relations between the factory and the dealer are distant and usually strained as the factory tries to force cars on the dealers to smooth out production. Relations between the dealer and the customer are equally strained because dealers continuously adjust prices—make deals—to adjust demand with supply while maximizing profits. This becomes a system marked by a lack of long-term commitment on either side, which maximizes feelings of mistrust. In order to maximize their bargaining positions, everyone holds back information—the dealer about the product and the consumer about his true desires. _________________
- As a result, ‘deal making’ becomes rampant, without concern for customer satisfaction.
- As a result, inefficiencies creep into the supply chain.
- As a result, everyone treats the other as an adversary, rather than as an ally.
- As a result, fundamental innovations are becoming scarce in the automobile industry.
- As a result, everyone loses in the long run.
From the options, we come to know that the question wants us to logically conclude the paragraph. So, the last line is a conclusion, not a continuation
Before we take the options, we must find out the central argument of the passage. What is the passage all about? The passage discusses the relations between three entities, and that relationship is strained. Now let’s take the options one at a time:
Option A: If the relations are strained, then how can deal-making become rampant?
Option B: The author is discussing strained relations; we must ask ‘how can strained relations cause inefficiencies in the supply chain?’ We don’t have strong pieces of evidence to arrive at such a conclusion.
Option C: Seems a good choice, but only at first glance. If the relations between the manufacturer and the distributor are not good, then they both will lose in the long run because they both depend on each other. And, how can the customer become an adversary of the manufacturer? The customer is competing neither with the manufacturer nor with the distributor. In short, option C is too far-fetched.
Option D: The issues with option D are very similar to those of option B. The logic of ‘strained relations vs innovations’ must be convincing. What has good or strained relations to do with innovations? The option does not sound convincing.
Option E: Sees perfect. Carefully read the last line of the passage: In order to maximize their bargaining positions, everyone holds back information—the dealer about the product and the consumer about his true desires. To maximize their bargaining positions, they are holding back information; as a result, they all will lose in the long run. The option is logical and sensible; it is not far-fetched or irrelevant as the others.
I request the students to study from the right source. Please don’t study from the material that is dubious.
Para Completion Questions for Practice
- Paracompletion Questions Set 01
- Paracompletion Questions Set 02
- Paracompletion Questions Set 03
- Paracompletion Questions Set 04
List of Articles on CAT Verbal Ability
- How to prepare for CAT Verbal Ability
- How to improve accuracy in Reading Comprehension
- How to Read RC Passages
- Reading Comprehension: Aricle of the Day
- 7 Easy Tips for CAT [RC] Reading Comprehension
- CAT RC : Macro and Micro Approach
- Types of Reading Comprehension Questions
- How to identify Tones of the RC Passages
- How to find main idea or central idea of the RC Passages
- How to solve inference based RC questions
- Types of Reading Comprehension Passages
- 5 most common mistakes made by students in CAT RCs
- How to approach CAT parajumbles
- CAT Para Summary Questions
- How to Solve CAT Odd sentences
- CAT Reading Comprehension: Should we read the questions first?
- If CAT Verbal Section is troubling you, read this
Previous Years CAT RC Passages PDF
CAT Verbal Ability (topic wise) Questions with Solutions
|Odd One Out (Odd Sentence)||Paragraph Summary|
|Daily articles to improve Reading Comprehension|