CAT Paragraph Summary Question 20

Question 20:

The passage given below is followed by four alternate summaries. Choose the option that best captures the essence of the passage.

For years, movies and television series like Crime Scene Investigation (CSI) paint an unrealistic picture of the “science of voices.” In the 1994 movie Clear and Present Danger an expert listens to a brief recorded utterance and declares that the speaker is “Cuban, aged 35 to 45, educated in the […] eastern United States.” The recording is then fed to a supercomputer that matches the voice to that of a suspect, concluding that the probability of correct identification is 90%. This sequence sums up a good number of misimpressions about forensic phonetics, which have led to errors in reallife  justice. Indeed, that movie scene exemplifies the so-called “CSI effect”—the phenomenon in which judges hold unrealistic expectations of the capabilities of forensic science.

  1. Although voice recognition is often presented as evidence in legal cases, its scientific basis can be shaky.
  2. Movies and televisions have led to the belief that the use of forensic phonetics in legal investigations is robust and fool proof.
  3. Voice recognition as used in many movies to identify criminals has been used to identify criminals in real life also.
  4. Voice recognition has started to feature prominently in crime-scene intelligence investigations because of movies and television series.
Option: 2

This question is slightly easier than the earlier one. Let’s see the critical elements of the passage. The most important critical element is “forensic phonetics in movies and television”, and “these have led to errors in real-life justice, with unrealistic expectations of the capabilities of forensic science”. 1 goes out because it misses the context of “movies and television”. 3 is a complete distortion, whereas 4 misses the “unrealistic expectations” part. 2 is the best choice in every way.

CAT 2021 Online Course @ INR 8999 only

Previous QuestionNext Question